claudemem-search
⚡ PRIMARY TOOL for semantic code search AND structural analysis. NEW: AST tree navigation with map, symbol, callers, callees, context commands. PageRank ranking. Recommended workflow: Map structure first, then search semantically, analyze callers before modifying.
Best use case
claudemem-search is best used when you need a repeatable AI agent workflow instead of a one-off prompt.
⚡ PRIMARY TOOL for semantic code search AND structural analysis. NEW: AST tree navigation with map, symbol, callers, callees, context commands. PageRank ranking. Recommended workflow: Map structure first, then search semantically, analyze callers before modifying.
Teams using claudemem-search should expect a more consistent output, faster repeated execution, less prompt rewriting.
When to use this skill
- You want a reusable workflow that can be run more than once with consistent structure.
When not to use this skill
- You only need a quick one-off answer and do not need a reusable workflow.
- You cannot install or maintain the underlying files, dependencies, or repository context.
Installation
Claude Code / Cursor / Codex
Manual Installation
- Download SKILL.md from GitHub
- Place it in
.claude/skills/claudemem-search/SKILL.mdinside your project - Restart your AI agent — it will auto-discover the skill
How claudemem-search Compares
| Feature / Agent | claudemem-search | Standard Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Platform Support | Not specified | Limited / Varies |
| Context Awareness | High | Baseline |
| Installation Complexity | Unknown | N/A |
Frequently Asked Questions
What does this skill do?
⚡ PRIMARY TOOL for semantic code search AND structural analysis. NEW: AST tree navigation with map, symbol, callers, callees, context commands. PageRank ranking. Recommended workflow: Map structure first, then search semantically, analyze callers before modifying.
Where can I find the source code?
You can find the source code on GitHub using the link provided at the top of the page.
Related Guides
Best AI Skills for Claude
Explore the best AI skills for Claude and Claude Code across coding, research, workflow automation, documentation, and agent operations.
ChatGPT vs Claude for Agent Skills
Compare ChatGPT and Claude for AI agent skills across coding, writing, research, and reusable workflow execution.
SKILL.md Source
# Claudemem Semantic Code Search Expert (v0.6.0)
This Skill provides comprehensive guidance on leveraging **claudemem** v0.7.0+ with **AST-based structural analysis**, **code analysis commands**, and **framework documentation** for intelligent codebase understanding.
## What's New in v0.3.0
```
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ CLAUDEMEM v0.3.0 ARCHITECTURE │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ │
│ ┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │
│ │ AST STRUCTURAL LAYER ⭐NEW │ │
│ │ Tree-sitter Parse → Symbol Graph → PageRank Ranking │ │
│ │ map | symbol | callers | callees | context │ │
│ └───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ │
│ ↓ │
│ ┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │
│ │ SEARCH LAYER │ │
│ │ Query → Embed → Vector Search + BM25 → Ranked Results │ │
│ └───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ │
│ ↓ │
│ ┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │
│ │ INDEX LAYER │ │
│ │ AST Parse → Chunk → Embed → LanceDB + Symbol Graph │ │
│ └───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ │
│ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
```
### Key Innovation: Structural Understanding
v0.3.0 adds **AST tree navigation** with symbol graph analysis:
- **PageRank ranking** - Symbols ranked by importance (how connected they are)
- **Call graph analysis** - Track callers/callees for impact assessment
- **Structural overview** - Map the codebase before reading code
---
## Quick Reference
```bash
# For agentic use, always use --agent flag for clean output
claudemem --agent <command>
# Core commands for agents
claudemem --agent map [query] # Get structural overview (repo map)
claudemem --agent symbol <name> # Find symbol definition
claudemem --agent callers <name> # What calls this symbol?
claudemem --agent callees <name> # What does this symbol call?
claudemem --agent context <name> # Full context (symbol + dependencies)
claudemem --agent search <query> # Semantic search (clean output)
claudemem --agent search <query> --map # Search + include repo map context
```
---
## Version Compatibility
Claudemem has evolved significantly. **Check your version** before using commands:
```bash
claudemem --version
```
### Command Availability by Version
| Command | Minimum Version | Status | Purpose |
|---------|-----------------|--------|---------|
| `map` | v0.3.0 | ✅ Available | Architecture overview with PageRank |
| `symbol` | v0.3.0 | ✅ Available | Find exact file:line location |
| `callers` | v0.3.0 | ✅ Available | What calls this symbol? |
| `callees` | v0.3.0 | ✅ Available | What does this symbol call? |
| `context` | v0.3.0 | ✅ Available | Full call chain (callers + callees) |
| `search` | v0.3.0 | ✅ Available | Semantic vector search |
| `dead-code` | v0.4.0+ | ⚠️ Check version | Find unused symbols |
| `test-gaps` | v0.4.0+ | ⚠️ Check version | Find high-importance untested code |
| `impact` | v0.4.0+ | ⚠️ Check version | BFS transitive caller analysis |
| `docs` | v0.7.0+ | ✅ Available | Framework documentation fetching |
### Version Detection in Scripts
```bash
# Get version number
VERSION=$(claudemem --version 2>/dev/null | grep -oE '[0-9]+\.[0-9]+\.[0-9]+' | head -1)
# Check if v0.4.0+ features available
if [ -n "$VERSION" ] && printf '%s\n' "0.4.0" "$VERSION" | sort -V -C; then
# v0.4.0+ available
claudemem --agent dead-code claudemem --agent test-gaps claudemem --agent impact SymbolNameelse
echo "Code analysis commands require claudemem v0.4.0+"
echo "Current version: $VERSION"
echo "Fallback to v0.3.0 commands (map, symbol, callers, callees)"
fi
```
### Graceful Degradation
When using v0.4.0+ commands, always provide fallback:
```bash
# Try impact analysis (v0.4.0+), fallback to callers (v0.3.0)
IMPACT=$(claudemem --agent impact SymbolName 2>/dev/null)
if [ -n "$IMPACT" ] && [ "$IMPACT" != "command not found" ]; then
echo "$IMPACT"
else
echo "Using fallback (direct callers only):"
claudemem --agent callers SymbolNamefi
```
**Why This Matters:**
- v0.3.0 commands work for 90% of use cases (navigation, modification)
- v0.4.0+ commands are specialized (code analysis, cleanup planning)
- Scripts should work across versions with appropriate fallbacks
---
## The Correct Workflow ⭐CRITICAL
### Phase 1: Understand Structure First (ALWAYS DO THIS)
Before reading any code files, get the structural overview:
```bash
# For a specific task, get focused repo map
claudemem --agent map "authentication flow"
# Output shows relevant symbols ranked by importance (PageRank):
# file: src/auth/AuthService.ts
# line: 15-89
# kind: class
# name: AuthService
# pagerank: 0.0921
# signature: class AuthService
# ---
# file: src/middleware/auth.ts
# ...
```
This tells you:
- Which files contain relevant code
- Which symbols are most important (high PageRank = heavily used)
- The structure before you read actual code
### Phase 2: Locate Specific Symbols
Once you know what to look for:
```bash
# Find exact location of a symbol
claudemem --agent symbol AuthService
# Output:
# file: src/auth/AuthService.ts
# line: 15-89
# kind: class
# name: AuthService
# signature: class AuthService implements IAuthProvider
# exported: true
# pagerank: 0.0921
# docstring: Handles user authentication and session management
```
### Phase 3: Understand Dependencies
Before modifying code, understand what depends on it:
```bash
# What calls AuthService? (impact of changes)
claudemem --agent callers AuthService
# Output:
# caller: LoginController.authenticate
# file: src/controllers/login.ts
# line: 34
# kind: call
# ---
# caller: SessionMiddleware.validate
# file: src/middleware/session.ts
# line: 12
# kind: call
```
```bash
# What does AuthService call? (its dependencies)
claudemem --agent callees AuthService
# Output:
# callee: Database.query
# file: src/db/database.ts
# line: 45
# kind: call
# ---
# callee: TokenManager.generate
# file: src/auth/tokens.ts
# line: 23
# kind: call
```
### Phase 4: Get Full Context
For complex modifications, get everything at once:
```bash
claudemem --agent context AuthService
# Output includes:
# [symbol]
# file: src/auth/AuthService.ts
# line: 15-89
# kind: class
# name: AuthService
# ...
# [callers]
# caller: LoginController.authenticate
# ...
# [callees]
# callee: Database.query
# ...
```
### Phase 5: Search for Code (Only If Needed)
When you need actual code snippets:
```bash
# Semantic search
claudemem --agent search "password hashing"
# Search with repo map context (recommended for complex tasks)
claudemem --agent search "password hashing" --map```
---
## Output Format
When using `--agent` flag, commands output machine-readable format:
```
# Raw output format (line-based, easy to parse)
file: src/core/indexer.ts
line: 45-120
kind: class
name: Indexer
signature: class Indexer
pagerank: 0.0842
exported: true
---
file: src/core/store.ts
line: 12-89
kind: class
name: VectorStore
...
```
Records are separated by `---`. Each field is `key: value` on its own line.
---
## Command Reference
### claudemem map [query]
Get structural overview of the codebase. Optionally focused on a query.
```bash
# Full repo map (top symbols by PageRank)
claudemem --agent map
# Focused on specific task
claudemem --agent map "authentication"
# Limit tokens
claudemem --agent map "auth" --tokens 500```
**Output fields**: file, line, kind, name, signature, pagerank, exported
**When to use**: Always first - understand structure before reading code
### claudemem symbol <name>
Find a symbol by name. Disambiguates using PageRank and export status.
```bash
claudemem --agent symbol Indexerclaudemem --agent symbol "search" --file retriever # hint which file
```
**Output fields**: file, line, kind, name, signature, pagerank, exported, docstring
**When to use**: When you know the symbol name and need exact location
### claudemem callers <name>
Find all symbols that call/reference the given symbol.
```bash
claudemem --agent callers AuthService```
**Output fields**: caller (name), file, line, kind (call/import/extends/etc)
**When to use**: Before modifying anything - know the impact radius
### claudemem callees <name>
Find all symbols that the given symbol calls/references.
```bash
claudemem --agent callees AuthService```
**Output fields**: callee (name), file, line, kind
**When to use**: To understand dependencies and trace data flow
### claudemem context <name>
Get full context: the symbol plus its callers and callees.
```bash
claudemem --agent context Indexerclaudemem --agent context Indexer --callers 10 --callees 20```
**Output sections**: [symbol], [callers], [callees]
**When to use**: For complex modifications requiring full awareness
### claudemem search <query>
Semantic search across the codebase.
```bash
claudemem --agent search "error handling"claudemem --agent search "error handling" --map # include repo map
claudemem --agent search "auth" -n 5 # limit results
```
**Output fields**: file, line, kind, name, score, content (truncated)
**When to use**: When you need actual code snippets (after mapping)
---
## Code Analysis Commands (v0.4.0+ Required)
### claudemem dead-code
Find unused symbols in the codebase.
```bash
# Find all unused symbols
claudemem --agent dead-code
# Stricter threshold (only very low PageRank)
claudemem --agent dead-code --max-pagerank 0.005
# Include exported symbols (usually excluded)
claudemem --agent dead-code --include-exported```
**Algorithm:**
- Zero callers (nothing references the symbol)
- Low PageRank (< 0.001 default)
- Not exported (by default, exports may be used externally)
**Output fields**: file, line, kind, name, pagerank, last_caller_removed
**When to use**: Architecture cleanup, tech debt assessment, before major refactoring
**Empty Result Handling:**
```bash
RESULT=$(claudemem --agent dead-code )
if [ -z "$RESULT" ] || [ "$RESULT" = "No dead code found" ]; then
echo "Codebase is clean - no dead code detected!"
echo "This indicates good code hygiene."
else
echo "$RESULT"
fi
```
**Static Analysis Limitations:**
- Dynamic imports (`import()`) may hide real callers
- Reflection-based access not captured
- External callers (other repos, CLI usage) not visible
- Exported symbols excluded by default for this reason
### claudemem test-gaps
Find high-importance code without test coverage.
```bash
# Find all test coverage gaps
claudemem --agent test-gaps
# Only critical gaps (high PageRank)
claudemem --agent test-gaps --min-pagerank 0.05```
**Algorithm:**
- High PageRank (> 0.01 default) - Important code
- Zero callers from test files (*.test.ts, *.spec.ts, *_test.go)
**Output fields**: file, line, kind, name, pagerank, production_callers, test_callers
**When to use**: Test coverage analysis, QA planning, identifying critical gaps
**Empty Result Handling:**
```bash
RESULT=$(claudemem --agent test-gaps )
if [ -z "$RESULT" ] || [ "$RESULT" = "No test gaps found" ]; then
echo "Excellent! All high-importance code has test coverage."
echo "Consider lowering --min-pagerank threshold for additional coverage."
else
echo "$RESULT"
fi
```
**Static Analysis Limitations:**
- Test file detection based on naming patterns only
- Integration tests calling code indirectly may not be detected
- Mocked dependencies may show false positives
### claudemem impact <symbol>
Analyze the impact of changing a symbol using BFS traversal.
```bash
# Get all transitive callers
claudemem --agent impact UserService
# Limit depth for large codebases
claudemem --agent impact UserService --max-depth 5```
**Algorithm:**
- BFS traversal from symbol to all transitive callers
- Groups results by depth level
- Shows file:line for each caller
**Output sections**: direct_callers, transitive_callers (with depth), grouped_by_file
**When to use**: Before ANY modification, refactoring planning, risk assessment
**Empty Result Handling:**
```bash
RESULT=$(claudemem --agent impact FunctionName )
if [ -z "$RESULT" ] || echo "$RESULT" | grep -q "No callers found"; then
echo "No callers found - this symbol appears unused or is an entry point."
echo "If unused, consider running: claudemem --agent dead-code "
echo "If entry point (API handler, main), this is expected."
else
echo "$RESULT"
fi
```
**Static Analysis Limitations:**
- Callback/event-based calls may not be detected
- Dependency injection containers hide static call relationships
- External service callers not visible
---
## LLM Enrichment Document Types (v0.2.0+)
Claudemem v0.2.0+ supports **LLM-enriched semantic search** with specialized document types.
### Document Types
| Type | Purpose | Generated By |
|------|---------|--------------|
| `symbol_summary` | Function behavior, params, returns, side effects | LLM analysis |
| `file_summary` | File purpose, exports, architectural patterns | LLM analysis |
| `idiom` | Common patterns in codebase | Pattern detection |
| `usage_example` | How to use APIs | Documentation extraction |
| `anti_pattern` | What NOT to do | Static analysis + LLM |
| `project_doc` | Project-level documentation | README, CLAUDE.md |
### Navigation Mode
For agent-optimized search with document type weighting:
```bash
# Navigation-focused search (prioritizes summaries)
claudemem --agent search "authentication" --use-case navigation
# Default search (balanced)
claudemem --agent search "authentication"```
**Navigation mode search weights:**
- `symbol_summary`: 1.5x (higher priority)
- `file_summary`: 1.3x (higher priority)
- `code_chunk`: 1.0x (normal)
- `idiom`: 1.2x (higher for pattern discovery)
### Symbol Summary Fields
```yaml
symbol: AuthService.authenticate
file: src/services/auth.ts
line: 45-89
behavior: "Validates user credentials and generates JWT token"
params:
- name: credentials
type: LoginCredentials
description: "Email and password from login form"
returns:
type: AuthResult
description: "JWT token and user profile on success, error on failure"
side_effects:
- "Updates user.lastLogin timestamp"
- "Logs authentication attempt"
- "May trigger rate limiting"
```
### File Summary Fields
```yaml
file: src/services/auth.ts
purpose: "Core authentication service handling login, logout, and session management"
exports:
- AuthService (class)
- authenticate (function)
- validateToken (function)
patterns:
- "Dependency Injection (constructor takes IUserRepository)"
- "Factory Pattern (createSession)"
- "Strategy Pattern (IAuthProvider interface)"
dependencies:
- bcrypt (password hashing)
- jsonwebtoken (JWT generation)
- UserRepository (user data access)
```
### Using Document Types in Investigation
```bash
# Find function behavior without reading code
claudemem --agent search "processPayment behavior" --use-case navigation
# Output includes symbol_summary:
# symbol: PaymentService.processPayment
# behavior: "Charges customer card via Stripe and saves transaction"
# side_effects: ["Updates balance", "Sends receipt email", "Logs to audit"]
# Find file purposes for architecture understanding
claudemem --agent search "file:services purpose" --use-case navigation
# Find anti-patterns to avoid
claudemem --agent search "anti_pattern SQL"```
### Regenerating Enrichments
If codebase changes significantly:
```bash
# Re-index with LLM enrichment
claudemem index --enrich
# Or enrich specific files
claudemem enrich src/services/payment.ts
```
---
## Workflow Templates
Standardized investigation patterns for common scenarios. All templates include error handling for empty results and version compatibility checks.
### Template 1: Bug Investigation
**Trigger:** "Why is X broken?", "Find bug", "Root cause"
```bash
# Step 1: Locate the symptom
SYMBOL=$(claudemem --agent symbol FunctionFromStackTrace )
if [ -z "$SYMBOL" ]; then
echo "Symbol not found - check spelling or run: claudemem --agent map 'related keywords' "
exit 1
fi
# Step 2: Get full context (callers + callees)
claudemem --agent context FunctionFromStackTrace
# Step 3: Trace backwards to find root cause
claudemem --agent callers suspectedSource
# Step 4: Check full impact of the bug (v0.4.0+)
IMPACT=$(claudemem --agent impact BuggyFunction 2>/dev/null)
if [ -n "$IMPACT" ]; then
echo "$IMPACT"
else
echo "Impact analysis requires claudemem v0.4.0+ or no callers found"
echo "Fallback: claudemem --agent callers BuggyFunction "
fi
# Step 5: Read identified file:line ranges
# Fix bug, verify callers still work
# Step 6: Document impacted code for testing
```
**Output Template:**
```markdown
## Bug Investigation Report
**Symptom:** [Description]
**Root Cause:** [Location and explanation]
**Call Chain:** [How we got here]
**Impact Radius:** [What else is affected]
**Fix Applied:** [What was changed]
**Verification:** [Tests run, callers checked]
```
### Template 2: New Feature Implementation
**Trigger:** "Add feature", "Implement X", "Extend functionality"
```bash
# Step 1: Map the feature area
MAP=$(claudemem --agent map "feature area keywords" )
if [ -z "$MAP" ]; then
echo "No matches found - try broader keywords"
fi
# Step 2: Identify extension points
claudemem --agent callees ExistingFeature
# Step 3: Get full context for modification point
claudemem --agent context ModificationPoint
# Step 4: Check existing patterns to follow
claudemem --agent search "similar pattern" --use-case navigation
# Step 5: Implement following existing patterns
# Step 6: Check test coverage gaps (v0.4.0+)
GAPS=$(claudemem --agent test-gaps 2>/dev/null)
if [ -n "$GAPS" ]; then
echo "Test gaps to address:"
echo "$GAPS"
else
echo "test-gaps requires v0.4.0+ or no gaps found"
fi
```
**Output Template:**
```markdown
## Feature Implementation Plan
**Feature:** [Description]
**Extension Point:** [Where to add]
**Dependencies:** [What it needs]
**Pattern to Follow:** [Existing similar code]
**Test Requirements:** [Coverage needs]
```
### Template 3: Refactoring
**Trigger:** "Rename X", "Extract function", "Move code", "Refactor"
```bash
# Step 1: Find the symbol to refactor
SYMBOL=$(claudemem --agent symbol SymbolToRename )
if [ -z "$SYMBOL" ]; then
echo "Symbol not found - check exact name"
exit 1
fi
# Step 2: Get FULL impact (all transitive callers) (v0.4.0+)
IMPACT=$(claudemem --agent impact SymbolToRename 2>/dev/null)
if [ -n "$IMPACT" ]; then
echo "$IMPACT"
# (impact output includes grouped_by_file)
else
echo "Using fallback (direct callers only):"
claudemem --agent callers SymbolToRenamefi
# Step 3: Group by file for systematic updates
# Step 4: Update each caller location systematically
# Step 5: Verify all callers updated
claudemem --agent callers NewSymbolName
# Step 6: Run affected tests
```
**Output Template:**
```markdown
## Refactoring Report
**Original:** [Old name/location]
**Target:** [New name/location]
**Direct Callers:** [Count]
**Transitive Callers:** [Count]
**Files Modified:** [List]
**Verification:** [All callers updated, tests pass]
```
### Template 4: Architecture Understanding
**Trigger:** "How does X work?", "Explain architecture", "Onboarding"
```bash
# Step 1: Get full structural map
MAP=$(claudemem --agent map )
if [ -z "$MAP" ]; then
echo "Index may be empty - run: claudemem index"
exit 1
fi
echo "$MAP"
# Step 2: Identify architectural pillars (PageRank > 0.05)
# Document top 5 by PageRank
# Step 3: For each pillar, get full context
claudemem --agent context PillarSymbol
# Step 4: Trace major flows via callees
claudemem --agent callees EntryPoint
# Step 5: Identify dead code (cleanup opportunities) (v0.4.0+)
DEAD=$(claudemem --agent dead-code 2>/dev/null)
if [ -n "$DEAD" ]; then
echo "Dead code found:"
echo "$DEAD"
else
echo "No dead code found (or v0.4.0+ required)"
fi
# Step 6: Identify test gaps (risk areas) (v0.4.0+)
GAPS=$(claudemem --agent test-gaps 2>/dev/null)
if [ -n "$GAPS" ]; then
echo "Test gaps:"
echo "$GAPS"
else
echo "No test gaps found (or v0.4.0+ required)"
fi
```
**Output Template:**
```markdown
## Architecture Report
**Core Abstractions (PageRank > 0.05):**
1. [Symbol] - [Role in system]
2. [Symbol] - [Role in system]
3. [Symbol] - [Role in system]
**Layer Structure:**
```
[Presentation Layer]
|
[Business Layer]
|
[Data Layer]
```
**Major Flows:**
- [Flow 1: Entry -> Processing -> Output]
- [Flow 2: Entry -> Processing -> Output]
**Health Indicators:**
- Dead Code: [Count] symbols
- Test Gaps: [Count] high-importance untested
- Tech Debt: [Summary]
```
### Template 5: Security Audit
**Trigger:** "Security review", "Audit authentication", "Check permissions"
```bash
# Step 1: Map security-related code
claudemem --agent map "auth permission security token"
# Step 2: Find authentication entry points
SYMBOL=$(claudemem --agent symbol authenticate )
if [ -z "$SYMBOL" ]; then
echo "No 'authenticate' symbol - try: login, verify, validate"
fi
claudemem --agent callers authenticate
# Step 3: Trace authentication flow
claudemem --agent callees authenticate
# Step 4: Check authorization patterns
claudemem --agent map "authorize permission check guard"
# Step 5: Find sensitive data handlers
claudemem --agent map "password hash token secret key"
# Step 6: Check for test coverage on security code (v0.4.0+)
GAPS=$(claudemem --agent test-gaps --min-pagerank 0.01 2>/dev/null)
if [ -n "$GAPS" ]; then
# Filter for security-related symbols
echo "$GAPS" | grep -E "(auth|login|password|token|permission|secret)"
fi
```
**Output Template:**
```markdown
## Security Audit Report
**Authentication:**
- Entry Points: [List]
- Flow: [Description]
- Gaps: [Issues found]
**Authorization:**
- Permission Checks: [Where implemented]
- Coverage: [All routes covered?]
**Sensitive Data:**
- Password Handling: [How stored/compared]
- Token Management: [Generation/validation]
- Secrets: [How managed]
**Test Coverage:**
- Security Code Coverage: [X%]
- Critical Gaps: [List]
**Recommendations:**
1. [Priority 1 fix]
2. [Priority 2 fix]
```
---
## Static Analysis Limitations
Claudemem uses static AST analysis. Some patterns are not captured:
### Dynamic Imports
```javascript
// NOT visible to static analysis
const module = await import(`./modules/${name}`);
```
**Result:** May show as "dead code" but is actually used dynamically.
**Action:** Mark as "Potentially Dead - Manual Review"
### External Callers
```javascript
// Exported for external use
export function publicAPI() { ... }
```
**Result:** May show 0 callers but used by other repositories.
**Action:** Use `--include-exported` carefully, or mark as "Externally Called - Manual Review Required"
### Reflection/Eval
```javascript
// NOT visible to static analysis
const fn = obj[methodName]();
eval("functionName()");
```
**Result:** Callers not detected.
**Action:** Search codebase for `eval`, `Object.keys`, bracket notation.
### Event-Driven Code
```javascript
// NOT visible as direct callers
emitter.on('event', handler);
document.addEventListener('click', onClick);
```
**Result:** `handler` and `onClick` may show 0 callers.
**Action:** Check for event registration patterns.
### Dependency Injection
```typescript
// Container registration hides relationships
container.register(IService, ServiceImpl);
```
**Result:** `ServiceImpl` may show 0 callers.
**Action:** Check DI container configuration.
---
## Scenarios
### Scenario 1: Bug Fix
**Task**: "Fix the null pointer exception in user authentication"
```bash
# Step 1: Get overview of auth-related code
claudemem --agent map "authentication null pointer"
# Step 2: Locate the specific symbol mentioned in error
claudemem --agent symbol authenticate
# Step 3: Check what calls it (to understand how it's used)
claudemem --agent callers authenticate
# Step 4: Read the actual code at the identified location
# Now you know exactly which file:line to read
```
### Scenario 2: Add New Feature
**Task**: "Add rate limiting to the API endpoints"
```bash
# Step 1: Understand API structure
claudemem --agent map "API endpoints rate"
# Step 2: Find the main API handler
claudemem --agent symbol APIController
# Step 3: See what the API controller depends on
claudemem --agent callees APIController
# Step 4: Check if rate limiting already exists somewhere
claudemem --agent search "rate limit"
# Step 5: Get full context for the modification point
claudemem --agent context APIController```
### Scenario 3: Refactoring
**Task**: "Rename DatabaseConnection to DatabasePool"
```bash
# Step 1: Find the symbol
claudemem --agent symbol DatabaseConnection
# Step 2: Find ALL callers (these all need updating)
claudemem --agent callers DatabaseConnection
# Step 3: The output shows every file:line that references it
# Update each location systematically
```
### Scenario 4: Understanding Unfamiliar Codebase
**Task**: "How does the indexing pipeline work?"
```bash
# Step 1: Get high-level structure
claudemem --agent map "indexing pipeline"
# Step 2: Find the main entry point (highest PageRank)
claudemem --agent symbol Indexer
# Step 3: Trace the flow - what does Indexer call?
claudemem --agent callees Indexer
# Step 4: For each major callee, get its callees
claudemem --agent callees VectorStoreclaudemem --agent callees FileTracker
# Now you have the full pipeline traced
```
---
## Token Efficiency Guide
| Action | Token Cost | When to Use |
|--------|------------|-------------|
| `map` (focused) | ~500 | Always first - understand structure |
| `symbol` | ~50 | When you know the name |
| `callers` | ~100-500 | Before modifying anything |
| `callees` | ~100-500 | To understand dependencies |
| `context` | ~200-800 | For complex modifications |
| `search` | ~1000-3000 | When you need actual code |
| `search --map` | ~1500-4000 | For unfamiliar codebases |
**Optimal order**: map → symbol → callers/callees → search (only if needed)
This pattern typically uses **80% fewer tokens** than blind exploration.
---
## Integration Pattern for Agents
For maximum efficiency, follow this pattern:
```
1. RECEIVE TASK
↓
2. claudemem --agent map "<task keywords>" → Understand structure, identify key symbols
↓
3. claudemem --agent symbol <high-pagerank-symbol> → Get exact location
↓
4. claudemem --agent callers <symbol> (if modifying)
→ Know the impact radius
↓
5. claudemem --agent callees <symbol> (if needed)
→ Understand dependencies
↓
6. READ specific file:line ranges (not whole files)
↓
7. MAKE CHANGES with full awareness
↓
8. CHECK callers still work
```
---
## PageRank: Understanding Symbol Importance
PageRank measures how "central" a symbol is in the codebase:
| PageRank | Meaning | Action |
|----------|---------|--------|
| > 0.05 | Core abstraction | Understand this first - everything depends on it |
| 0.01-0.05 | Important symbol | Key functionality, worth understanding |
| 0.001-0.01 | Standard symbol | Normal code, read as needed |
| < 0.001 | Utility/leaf | Helper functions, read only if directly relevant |
**Why PageRank matters**:
- High-PageRank symbols are heavily used → understand them first
- Low-PageRank symbols are utilities → read later if needed
- Focus on high-PageRank symbols to understand architecture quickly
---
## 💡 Better Approaches (Recommended Patterns)
Claudemem provides more efficient alternatives to common search patterns:
| Instead of... | Try this | Benefit |
|---------------|----------|---------|
| `cat src/core/*.ts \| head -1000` | `claudemem --agent map "task"` | Saves tokens, finds relevant files |
| `grep -r "Database" src/` | `claudemem --agent symbol Database` | Semantic relationships, not just strings |
| Edit without caller check | `claudemem --agent callers X` first | Know what depends on your changes |
| Search immediately | `map` first, then `search` | Context improves search accuracy |
| Read every matching file | Focus on high-PageRank symbols | Core code first, utilities later |
| `claudemem search "query"` | `claudemem --agent search "query"` | Clean output without ASCII art |
### Why These Patterns Work Better
1. **Token Efficiency**: `map` identifies relevant files before reading, avoiding wasted context
2. **Semantic Understanding**: `symbol` and `callers` understand code relationships, not just text
3. **Impact Awareness**: `callers` reveals dependencies before you modify code
4. **PageRank Guidance**: High-PageRank symbols are heavily connected - understand them first
### Output Handling
## Tip: Use Complete Claudemem Output
Results are ranked by PageRank - most important symbols appear first.
Using the complete output ensures you see all relevant results.
### Managing Large Output
If output is too large, use built-in flags instead of truncating:
| Flag | Purpose | Example |
|------|---------|---------|
| `--tokens N` | Limit by token count | `claudemem --agent map "query" --tokens 2000` |
| `-n N` | Limit result count | `claudemem --agent search "auth" -n 10` |
| `--page-size N` | Pagination | `claudemem --agent search "x" --page-size 20` |
| `--max-depth N` | Limit traversal | `claudemem --agent context Func --max-depth 3` |
**Tip:** Piping to file preserves full output: `claudemem --agent map "query" > /tmp/map.txt`
### Quick Reference: Recommended Patterns
| Instead of... | Try this | Why |
|--------------|----------|-----|
| Read files blindly | `map` first, then read specific lines | Ranked results, less tokens |
| `grep -r "auth"` | `claudemem --agent symbol auth` | Semantic understanding |
| Modify without callers | `callers` before any modification | Avoid breaking changes |
| Search immediately | `map` → `symbol` → search | Structural context first |
| `cmd \| head` | Use `-n` or `--tokens` flags | Output is pre-optimized |
---
## The Correct Workflow Diagram
```
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ CORRECT INVESTIGATION FLOW (v0.3.0) │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ │
│ 1. claudemem --agent map "task" │
│ → Understand structure, find high-PageRank symbols │
│ │
│ 2. claudemem --agent symbol <name> │
│ → Get exact file:line location │
│ │
│ 3. claudemem --agent callers <name> │
│ → Know impact radius BEFORE modifying │
│ │
│ 4. claudemem --agent callees <name> │
│ → Understand dependencies │
│ │
│ 5. Read specific file:line ranges (NOT whole files) │
│ │
│ 6. Make changes with full awareness │
│ │
│ ⚠️ NEVER: Start with Read/Glob for semantic questions │
│ ⚠️ NEVER: Modify without checking callers │
│ ⚠️ NEVER: Search without mapping first │
│ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
```
---
## Installation & Setup
### Check Installation
```bash
# Check if claudemem CLI is available
which claudemem || command -v claudemem
# Check version (must be 0.3.0+)
claudemem --version
```
### Installation Options
```bash
# npm (recommended)
npm install -g claude-codemem
# Homebrew (macOS)
brew tap MadAppGang/claude-mem && brew install --cask claudemem
```
### Index Codebase
```bash
# Index current project
claudemem index
# Check status
claudemem --version && ls -la .claudemem/index.db 2>/dev/null
```
---
## Framework Documentation (v0.7.0+) ⭐NEW
Claudemem v0.7.0+ includes **automatic framework documentation fetching** for your project dependencies. Documentation is indexed alongside your code, enabling unified semantic search across both.
### Quick Reference
```bash
# Core documentation commands
claudemem docs status # Show indexed libraries and cache state
claudemem docs fetch # Fetch docs for all detected dependencies
claudemem docs fetch react vue # Fetch specific libraries
claudemem docs providers # List available documentation providers
claudemem docs refresh # Force refresh all cached documentation
claudemem docs clear # Clear all documentation cache
claudemem docs clear react # Clear specific library cache
```
### Documentation Providers
Claudemem uses a **provider hierarchy** with automatic fallback:
| Priority | Provider | Coverage | Requirements |
|----------|----------|----------|--------------|
| 1 (Best) | **Context7** | 6000+ libraries with versioned code examples | API key (free tier available) |
| 2 | **llms.txt** | Official AI-friendly docs from framework sites | Free, no key needed |
| 3 | **DevDocs** | Consistent offline documentation, 100+ languages | Free, no key needed |
### Dependency Detection
Claudemem automatically detects dependencies from:
| File | Ecosystem | Example |
|------|-----------|---------|
| `package.json` | npm/yarn | React, Vue, Express |
| `requirements.txt` | Python/pip | Django, FastAPI, Pandas |
| `go.mod` | Go | Gin, Echo, GORM |
| `Cargo.toml` | Rust | Tokio, Actix, Serde |
### Setup
```bash
# Option 1: Run init (includes docs configuration)
claudemem init
# Option 2: Configure Context7 manually (optional, for best coverage)
export CONTEXT7_API_KEY=your_key
# Get free API key at: https://context7.com/dashboard
```
### Usage Examples
```bash
# Check current documentation status
claudemem docs status
# Output:
# 📚 Documentation Status
#
# Enabled: Yes
# Providers: Context7, llms.txt, DevDocs
# Libraries: 12 indexed
# Cache Age: 2h 15m
#
# Indexed Libraries:
# react (v18) via Context7 - 145 chunks
# typescript (v5) via Context7 - 89 chunks
# express (v4) via llms.txt - 34 chunks
# ...
# Fetch documentation for all project dependencies
claudemem docs fetch
# Output:
# 📚 Fetching Documentation
#
# [1/8] react... ✓ 145 chunks via Context7
# [2/8] typescript... ✓ 89 chunks via Context7
# [3/8] express... ✓ 34 chunks via llms.txt
# [4/8] lodash... ✓ 67 chunks via DevDocs
# ...
# Fetch specific library
claudemem docs fetch fastapi
# View available providers
claudemem docs providers
# Force refresh (clears cache, refetches)
claudemem docs refresh
```
### Unified Search (Code + Documentation)
After indexing documentation, `claudemem search` returns results from **both** your codebase **and** framework documentation:
```bash
claudemem --agent search "how to use React hooks"
# Output includes:
# --- Your Code ---
# file: src/components/UserProfile.tsx
# line: 12-45
# kind: function
# name: useUserProfile
# score: 0.89
# content: Custom hook for user profile management...
# ---
# --- React Documentation ---
# library: react
# section: Hooks Reference
# title: useEffect
# score: 0.87
# content: The useEffect Hook lets you perform side effects...
# ---
# library: react
# section: Hooks Reference
# title: useState
# score: 0.85
# content: useState is a Hook that lets you add state...
```
### When to Use Documentation Commands
| Scenario | Command | Why |
|----------|---------|-----|
| New project setup | `claudemem docs fetch` | Index docs for all dependencies |
| Learning new library | `claudemem docs fetch <library>` | Get searchable reference |
| Updated dependencies | `claudemem docs refresh` | Refresh to get new versions |
| Check what's indexed | `claudemem docs status` | View cache state |
| Clear space | `claudemem docs clear` | Remove cached documentation |
### Integration with Investigation Workflow
Add documentation fetch to your investigation workflow:
```bash
# ENHANCED Investigation Workflow (v0.7.0+)
# Step 0: Ensure framework docs are available (one-time)
claudemem docs status || claudemem docs fetch
# Step 1: Map architecture (now includes library patterns)
claudemem --agent map "authentication"
# Step 2: Search both code AND framework docs
claudemem --agent search "JWT token validation"# Returns: your auth code + library docs on JWT handling
# Step 3: Understand how the library recommends usage
claudemem --agent search "react best practices hooks"# Returns: your patterns + React official guidance
```
### Version Information
The `claudemem docs` command requires **v0.7.0+**. Check your version:
```bash
claudemem --version
# Expected: 0.7.0 or higher
```
**Note:** If `claudemem docs help` returns "Unknown command", upgrade your claudemem installation.
---
## Search Feedback Protocol (v0.8.0+) ⭐NEW
Claudemem learns from your search patterns. After completing a task, report which search results were helpful to improve future searches.
### Why Feedback Matters
| Feedback Type | Effect | Over Time |
|---------------|--------|-----------|
| Helpful | +10% boost | Files you consistently use rank higher |
| Unhelpful | -10% demotion | Irrelevant results rank lower |
| Document Type | Type weighting | Helpful types (e.g., symbol_summary) get priority |
### CLI Interface
```bash
# After using search results, report feedback
claudemem feedback --query "your original query" \
--helpful id1,id2 \
--unhelpful id3,id4
# Result IDs are shown in search output:
claudemem search "authentication" --agent# Output includes:
# id: abc123
# file: src/auth/middleware.ts
# ...
```
### MCP Interface
```json
{
"tool": "report_search_feedback",
"arguments": {
"query": "authentication flow",
"allResultIds": ["id1", "id2", "id3"],
"helpfulIds": ["id1"],
"unhelpfulIds": ["id3"]
}
}
```
### When to Track as Helpful
A result should be marked as **helpful** when:
- The file was read and contained relevant information
- The code was used to understand the problem
- The symbol was part of the call chain being traced
- The file contributed to the final answer
### When to Track as Unhelpful
A result should be marked as **unhelpful** when:
- The file was read but contained irrelevant information
- The result was a false positive (matched query but wrong context)
- The file was skipped after reading initial content
- The symbol was not related to the investigation
### When NOT to Track
Do not track feedback for:
- Results from `map` command (structural overview, not semantic search)
- Results from `symbol` command (exact lookup, not search)
- Results from `callers`/`callees` commands (call graph, not search)
- Only `search` command results should have feedback
### Integration with Workflow Templates
Add feedback reporting to the end of each workflow template:
```bash
# Template 1: Bug Investigation (add at end)
# Step 7: Report feedback
if [ -n "$SEARCH_QUERY" ] && [ -n "$HELPFUL_IDS" ]; then
# Check if feedback is available (v0.8.0+)
if claudemem feedback --help 2>&1 | grep -qi "feedback"; then
timeout 5 claudemem feedback --query "$SEARCH_QUERY" \
--helpful "${HELPFUL_IDS}" \
--unhelpful "${UNHELPFUL_IDS}" 2>/dev/null || true
else
echo "Note: Search feedback requires claudemem v0.8.0+"
fi
fi
```
### Feedback Workflow Example
```bash
# Full investigation with feedback tracking
# 0. Check if feedback is available (v0.8.0+)
FEEDBACK_AVAILABLE=false
if claudemem feedback --help 2>&1 | grep -qi "feedback"; then
FEEDBACK_AVAILABLE=true
else
echo "Note: Search feedback requires claudemem v0.8.0+"
fi
# 1. Search and capture IDs
RESULTS=$(claudemem --agent search "payment processing" -n 10 )
ALL_IDS=$(echo "$RESULTS" | grep "^id:" | awk '{print $2}')
SEARCH_QUERY="payment processing"
# 2. Initialize tracking arrays
HELPFUL=()
UNHELPFUL=()
# 3. Process results (during investigation)
# When you read a result and it's useful:
HELPFUL+=("abc123")
# When you read a result and it's not relevant:
UNHELPFUL+=("def456")
# 4. Report feedback (at end of investigation)
if [ "$FEEDBACK_AVAILABLE" = true ] && ([ ${#HELPFUL[@]} -gt 0 ] || [ ${#UNHELPFUL[@]} -gt 0 ]); then
timeout 5 claudemem feedback \
--query "$SEARCH_QUERY" \
--helpful "$(IFS=,; echo "${HELPFUL[*]}")" \
--unhelpful "$(IFS=,; echo "${UNHELPFUL[*]}")" \
2>/dev/null || echo "Note: Feedback not sent (optional)"
fi
```
### Quality Checklist Update
Add to the existing Quality Checklist:
- [ ] **Tracked result IDs during search** (if using `search` command)
- [ ] **Reported feedback at end of investigation** (if applicable)
---
## Index Freshness Check (v0.5.0)
Before proceeding with investigation, verify the index is current:
```bash
# Count files modified since last index
STALE_COUNT=$(find . -type f \( -name "*.ts" -o -name "*.tsx" -o -name "*.js" -o -name "*.jsx" -o -name "*.py" -o -name "*.go" -o -name "*.rs" \) \
-newer .claudemem/index.db 2>/dev/null | grep -v "node_modules" | grep -v ".git" | grep -v "dist" | grep -v "build" | wc -l)
STALE_COUNT=$((STALE_COUNT + 0)) # Normalize to integer
if [ "$STALE_COUNT" -gt 0 ]; then
# Get index time with explicit platform detection
if [[ "$OSTYPE" == "darwin"* ]]; then
INDEX_TIME=$(stat -f "%Sm" -t "%Y-%m-%d %H:%M" .claudemem/index.db 2>/dev/null)
else
INDEX_TIME=$(stat -c "%y" .claudemem/index.db 2>/dev/null | cut -d'.' -f1)
fi
INDEX_TIME=${INDEX_TIME:-"unknown time"}
# Use AskUserQuestion to ask user how to proceed
# Options: [1] Reindex now (Recommended), [2] Proceed with stale index, [3] Cancel
fi
```
**AskUserQuestion Template:**
```typescript
AskUserQuestion({
questions: [{
question: `${STALE_COUNT} files have been modified since the last index (${INDEX_TIME}). The claudemem index may be outdated, which could cause missing or incorrect results. How would you like to proceed?`,
header: "Index Freshness Warning",
multiSelect: false,
options: [
{
label: "Reindex now (Recommended)",
description: "Run claudemem index to update. Takes ~1-2 minutes."
},
{
label: "Proceed with stale index",
description: "Continue investigation. May miss recent code changes."
},
{
label: "Cancel investigation",
description: "I'll handle this manually."
}
]
}]
})
```
---
## Result Validation Guidelines
### After Every Command
1. **Check exit code** - Non-zero indicates failure
2. **Check for empty results** - May need reindex or different query
3. **Validate relevance** - Results should match query semantics
### Validation Examples
```bash
# map validation
RESULTS=$(claudemem --agent map "authentication" )
EXIT_CODE=$?
if [ "$EXIT_CODE" -ne 0 ]; then
echo "ERROR: claudemem command failed"
# Diagnose index health
DIAGNOSIS=$(claudemem --version && ls -la .claudemem/index.db 2>&1)
# Use AskUserQuestion
fi
if [ -z "$RESULTS" ]; then
echo "WARNING: No results found - may need reindex or different query"
# Use AskUserQuestion
fi
if ! echo "$RESULTS" | grep -qi "auth\|login\|user\|session"; then
echo "WARNING: Results may not be relevant to authentication query"
# Use AskUserQuestion
fi
# symbol validation
RESULTS=$(claudemem --agent symbol UserService )
if ! echo "$RESULTS" | grep -q "name: UserService"; then
echo "WARNING: UserService not found - check spelling or reindex"
# Use AskUserQuestion
fi
# search validation
RESULTS=$(claudemem --agent search "error handling" )
MATCH_COUNT=0
for kw in error handling catch try; do
if echo "$RESULTS" | grep -qi "$kw"; then
MATCH_COUNT=$((MATCH_COUNT + 1))
fi
done
if [ "$MATCH_COUNT" -lt 2 ]; then
echo "WARNING: Results may not be relevant to error handling query"
# Use AskUserQuestion
fi
```
---
## Fallback Options
If claudemem returns no results or the index isn't available:
1. **Check index status** - Run `claudemem status` to verify
2. **Try different query** - Rephrase or use more specific terms
3. **Reindex if needed** - Run `claudemem index` (~1-2 min)
4. **Native tools available** - grep/Glob work but without semantic ranking
### Using Native Tools
Native search tools (grep, Glob, find) are available when needed. They work well for:
- Exact string matches
- File pattern searches
- When the index isn't available
For bypass, use: `_bypass_claudemem: true` in tool input.
### Comparison
| Feature | claudemem | grep/Glob |
|---------|-----------|-----------|
| Semantic understanding | ✓ | - |
| Call graph analysis | ✓ | - |
| PageRank ranking | ✓ | - |
| Exact string match | ✓ | ✓ |
| Works without index | - | ✓ |
**Tip:** After using native tools, consider running `claudemem index` to enable
semantic search for future investigations.
**See ultrathink-detective skill for complete Fallback Protocol documentation.**
---
## Quality Checklist
Before completing a claudemem workflow, ensure:
- [ ] claudemem CLI is installed (v0.3.0+)
- [ ] Codebase is indexed (check with `claudemem status`)
- [ ] **Checked index freshness** before starting ⭐NEW in v0.5.0
- [ ] **Started with `map`** to understand structure ⭐CRITICAL
- [ ] Used `--agent` for all commands
- [ ] **Validated results after every command** ⭐NEW in v0.5.0
- [ ] Checked `callers` before modifying any symbol
- [ ] Focused on high-PageRank symbols first
- [ ] Read only specific file:line ranges (not whole files)
- [ ] **Never silently switched to grep** ⭐NEW in v0.5.0
- [ ] **Reported search feedback** if `search` command was used ⭐NEW in v0.8.0
---
## Notes
- Requires OpenRouter API key for embeddings (https://openrouter.ai)
- Default model: `voyage/voyage-code-3` (best code understanding)
- All data stored locally in `.claudemem/` directory
- Tree-sitter provides AST parsing for TypeScript, Go, Python, Rust
- PageRank based on symbol call graph analysis
- Can run as MCP server with `--mcp` flag
- Initial indexing takes ~1-2 minutes for typical projects
- **NEW in v0.3.0**: `map`, `symbol`, `callers`, `callees`, `context` commands
- **NEW in v0.3.0**: PageRank ranking for symbol importance
- **NEW in v0.3.0**: `--agent` flag for clean, parseable output
- **NEW in v0.4.0**: `dead-code`, `test-gaps`, `impact` commands for code analysis
- **NEW in v0.4.0**: BFS traversal for transitive caller analysis
- **NEW in v0.7.0**: `docs` command for framework documentation fetching
- **NEW in v0.7.0**: Context7, llms.txt, DevDocs documentation providers
- **NEW in v0.7.0**: Unified search across code AND framework documentation
- **NEW in v0.7.0**: Auto-detection of dependencies from package.json, requirements.txt, go.mod, Cargo.toml
---
**Maintained by:** Jack Rudenko @ MadAppGang
**Plugin:** code-analysis v2.8.0
**Last Updated:** December 2025 (v0.8.0 - Search feedback protocol)Related Skills
search-interceptor
💡 Bulk file read optimizer. Suggests semantic search alternatives when reading multiple files. Helps reduce token usage by using claudemem's ranked results instead of sequential file reads.
code-search-selector
💡 Tool selector for code search tasks. Helps choose between semantic search (claudemem) and native tools (Grep/Glob) based on query type. Semantic search recommended for: 'how does X work', 'find all', 'audit', 'investigate', 'architecture'.
claudemem-orchestration
Use when orchestrating multi-agent code analysis with claudemem. Run claudemem once, share output across parallel agents. Enables parallel investigation, consensus analysis, and role-based command mapping.
test-skill
A test skill for validation testing. Use when testing skill parsing and validation logic.
bad-skill
This skill has invalid YAML in frontmatter
release
Plugin release process for MAG Claude Plugins marketplace. Covers version bumping, marketplace.json updates, git tagging, and common mistakes. Use when releasing new plugin versions or troubleshooting update issues.
openrouter-trending-models
Fetch trending programming models from OpenRouter rankings. Use when selecting models for multi-model review, updating model recommendations, or researching current AI coding trends. Provides model IDs, context windows, pricing, and usage statistics from the most recent week.
Claudish Integration Skill
**Version:** 1.0.0
transcription
Audio/video transcription using OpenAI Whisper. Covers installation, model selection, transcript formats (SRT, VTT, JSON), timing synchronization, and speaker diarization. Use when transcribing media or generating subtitles.
final-cut-pro
Apple Final Cut Pro FCPXML format reference. Covers project structure, timeline creation, clip references, effects, and transitions. Use when generating FCP projects or understanding FCPXML structure.
ffmpeg-core
FFmpeg fundamentals for video/audio manipulation. Covers common operations (trim, concat, convert, extract), codec selection, filter chains, and performance optimization. Use when planning or executing video processing tasks.
statusline-customization
Configuration reference and troubleshooting for the statusline plugin — sections, themes, bar widths, and script architecture